What Manufacturers Keep Missing About Cycling Power Meters
I love my video doorbell. I won't mention the brand, but you've probably seen it advertised. What I like most about it is its simplicity and ease of use right out of the box. I quickly understood what its capabilities were, it took approximately ten minutes to set up, and it has been working reliably ever since. It features seamless firmware updates, intuitive app-based controls, and robust hardware. This is technology as it should be, and it was likely designed with people who dislike complicated technology in mind.
I've been using, coaching with, and selling cycling power meters for over three decades, and I've watched the industry gradually move toward this type of consumer-centric thinking. Having worked with athletes as a coach long before becoming a retailer, I tend to approach power meters from the perspective of the end user. I've witnessed former industry leaders fail to adapt to changing consumer demands, while other manufacturers successfully reinvented their products. Despite considerable technological advancement, power meters remain somewhat confusing to many cyclists, and I frequently encounter customers making purchasing decisions based on features they may never use.
Are Power Meter Manufacturers Designing for the Wrong Customer?
Power measurement technology has evolved considerably. Power meters have been incorporated into crank spiders, crank arms, pedals, rear hubs, bottom brackets, and even bicycle frames. Each design has its advantages and disadvantages in terms of accuracy, compatibility, portability, durability, and price. Over the years, I've listened to representatives from various manufacturers explain why certain power meter designs were impractical or impossible. Some of the companies attempting those supposedly impossible designs are now selling a lot of power meters.
If I were to categorize the power-trained athletes I've worked with over the years, I would roughly divide them into four groups:
-
5% – Data junkies: These athletes love analyzing their data to the nth degree and are convinced their next performance breakthrough is hidden somewhere in the numbers. They frequently drive their coaches, and sometimes themselves, nuts.
-
30% – Tech-savvy athletes: These athletes regularly upload and analyze their training data, understand its application, and use it to make informed training decisions without becoming overwhelmed by it. For these athletes, a power meter is generally an excellent investment.
-
45% – Tech-tolerant athletes: These cyclists use their power meters during workouts but may upload or analyze their data inconsistently. They don't necessarily have the time or patience for complex analysis and may rely on a coach to interpret their training information.
-
20% – Tech-averse athletes: These athletes probably purchased a power meter because a friend, coach, or marketing campaign convinced them they needed one. It often becomes little more than an expensive cycling computer displaying numbers they don't fully understand.
Before the data junkies take issue with these percentages, they are not the results of a scientific study. They are simply rough estimates based on my own subjective coaching experiences (please don't report me to DC Rainmaker).
My point is that, in my opinion, power meter manufacturers spent far too many years designing and marketing products for the top 5%. There was a time when power meters were expensive, specialized tools used primarily by highly competitive cyclists and coaches willing to make a substantial investment. As prices declined and the market expanded, the typical power meter customer changed. Product design and marketing needed to change with it.
More Data Does Not Necessarily Make You Faster
One of the problems with consumer electronics is the tendency for manufacturers to continually add features without considering whether those features improve the user experience. Multisport watches are an excellent example. What began as relatively straightforward devices for monitoring heart rate, pace, and distance evolved into sophisticated computers capable of measuring an enormous number of variables. Many of these features are genuinely useful, but I suspect the average athlete regularly uses only a fraction of what their device is capable of.
Manufacturers have a natural incentive to introduce new features because they help differentiate products and provide reasons for consumers to upgrade. The problem arises when additional complexity makes the fundamental functions of a device more difficult to access. A cyclist shouldn't have to navigate multiple screens to find the handful of metrics necessary to complete a workout.
Power meter users experienced similar growing pains. Some early power meters required the removal and return of an entire crank assembly simply to replace a battery. Today's better-designed systems offer wireless connectivity, app-based configuration, accessible batteries or rechargeable designs, and relatively straightforward firmware updates. These improvements may not sound particularly exciting compared to a new performance metric, but they have made power meters considerably more practical.
As a consumer, you shouldn't base your purchasing decision exclusively on which power meter has the most features or which one is considered the most technologically advanced. The better question is how much technology you actually need and whether additional features will improve the effectiveness of your training.
Single-Sided vs. Dual-Sided Power Meters: Do You Need Both?
Left/right power analysis is a good example of a feature that sounds considerably more useful than it may be for the average cyclist.
A true dual-sided power meter independently measures the power produced by each leg, allowing the cyclist to examine differences between left and right power output. A single-sided power meter typically measures one leg and doubles that measurement to estimate total power. Some other systems estimate left/right contribution without independently measuring each leg, so it is important to understand exactly what a manufacturer is offering.
The first thing to recognize is that a perfectly symmetrical 50/50 power distribution is not necessarily an appropriate objective. Many cyclists exhibit some degree of asymmetry, and that distribution may change with fatigue, cadence, intensity, riding position, and other factors.
A difference in left/right power production may be associated with previous injuries, functional strength differences, leg-length discrepancies, bicycle fit, or pedaling mechanics. However, the power meter itself generally cannot tell you why the difference exists, whether it represents a meaningful problem, or how to correct it.
This information may be valuable during rehabilitation, a comprehensive bike fitting, or a detailed assessment of cycling mechanics. It can also help identify situations in which a single-sided power meter may produce misleading estimates of total power. But simply knowing that your left leg produces 48% of your power and your right leg produces 52% doesn't necessarily provide actionable information.
Improving economy of movement in any sport requires identifying a meaningful limitation and then applying appropriate corrective techniques. This is where an experienced coach, bike fitter, or other qualified professional can be particularly helpful.
Interestingly, one of the least expensive pieces of technology I've used to provide athletes with feedback on their cycling mechanics is a mirror. Setting up an indoor trainer in front of a mirror allows the cyclist to observe certain aspects of their movement in real time. Video analysis can provide additional information about pedaling mechanics and body position.
The point is not that advanced power metrics have no value. It is that their value depends entirely on the athlete's ability to interpret and apply them. Unless you have a specific reason to collect additional data, a more affordable single-sided power meter may accomplish most of what you need.
Power Meter Accuracy vs. Consistency
Accuracy is one of the most heavily marketed power meter specifications, but it deserves some perspective. Many modern cycling power meters advertise accuracy within approximately ±1% to ±2%, although actual performance depends on the device, installation, operating conditions, and measurement method.
Will purchasing a power meter with a claimed accuracy improvement of half a percentage point make you a better cyclist? For the vast majority of recreational and competitive athletes, probably not.
From a coaching perspective, consistency and repeatability are extraordinarily important. If an athlete's power meter consistently reports reliable measurements, those measurements can be used to establish training zones, monitor progress, prescribe intervals, and develop pacing strategies. A device that produces erratic readings, experiences signal interruptions, or changes its measurement characteristics unpredictably is considerably less useful, regardless of its advertised accuracy.
That said, absolute accuracy becomes more important when comparing data between different bicycles, indoor smart trainers, power meters, or laboratory testing equipment. A substantial discrepancy between devices can cause problems when prescribing precise training intensities. Single-sided measurement can also introduce additional variation when an athlete's left/right power distribution changes.
I would place considerable emphasis on reliable operation, temperature compensation, appropriate zero-offset procedures, and consistent measurement under real-world riding conditions. These practical considerations often deserve more attention than small differences in advertised accuracy.
Connectivity, Compatibility and Flexibility Matter
One of the most valuable features of a modern cycling power meter is flexibility. This applies not only to transferring the power meter between bicycles but also to the cycling computers, smartphones, training applications, and software platforms that can receive and interpret its data.
I generally prefer power meters that support both ANT+ and Bluetooth Low Energy where appropriate. These communication standards allow compatible power meters to transmit information to a wide variety of cycling computers, smartwatches, indoor training platforms, and mobile applications. Many power meters also use a manufacturer's smartphone app for configuration, battery monitoring, calibration functions, and firmware updates.
The fundamental purpose of a power meter is to measure mechanical power, generally by measuring or estimating torque and rotational speed. The receiving device or software can then use this information to calculate and display various performance metrics. The power meter doesn't need to independently provide every piece of analysis an athlete might eventually want.
While riding outdoors, you can effectively and safely monitor only a limited amount of information. I generally encourage athletes to display the metrics most relevant to the workout or race rather than attempting to monitor everything simultaneously. A short rolling power average, lap average power, elapsed time, and perhaps cadence or heart rate may provide all the information necessary to execute many structured workouts. More detailed analysis can be performed afterward.
Compatibility is particularly important for cyclists who train both indoors and outdoors. Using the same power meter as a reference across training environments can help maintain consistency, provided the equipment and applications support that arrangement.
A power meter that integrates seamlessly into your existing equipment and training routine is often a much better investment than a technically superior device that requires you to change everything else you own.
How to Choose the Right Cycling Power Meter
When assisting a customer with a power meter purchase, I generally begin by establishing an approximate budget. There is a considerable difference in price between an entry-level single-sided crank-arm power meter and a premium dual-sided pedal or crank-based system. Establishing a budget immediately helps narrow the options and keeps the discussion focused on products that make sense for the customer.
Compatibility is the next consideration. Modern bicycles feature a wide variety of cranksets, bottom bracket standards, spindle designs, chainring configurations, and frame clearances. Pedal-based power meters simplify some compatibility issues, but factors such as cleat preference, crank clearance, pedal stack height, and intended riding discipline still need to be considered. A power meter that doesn't fit your bicycle is of little value, regardless of how attractive its specifications may be.
Once budget and compatibility have been established, I generally ask the following questions:
-
Do you want to use the same power meter on multiple bicycles?
-
Do you primarily ride road, gravel, mountain bikes, or triathlon bikes?
-
Do you need compatibility with a particular cycling computer or training application?
-
Do you train both indoors and outdoors?
-
Would independent left/right power measurement provide meaningful information?
-
Do you prefer rechargeable batteries or easily replaceable batteries?
-
How much time and patience do you have for configuring and maintaining the device?
-
What kind of warranty and technical support does the manufacturer provide?
The last question is particularly important and frequently overlooked. As a retailer, I've worked with manufacturers whose products rarely have problems and whose warranty departments respond promptly when something does go wrong. I've also encountered situations where resolving a relatively straightforward issue became unnecessarily difficult.
A power meter is a training tool that may be used several times per week for many years. Product reliability, replacement-part availability, technical support, and warranty service should all be considered part of its value.
Don't Be Too Eager to Adopt the Latest Technology
As cycling power meter prices have declined, the market has expanded considerably, attracting both established manufacturers and newcomers. Competition is generally beneficial to consumers because it creates more options, encourages innovation, and places downward pressure on pricing.
However, I don't necessarily recommend being an early adopter of every new power measurement technology. It takes time for manufacturers to identify and resolve problems that may not become apparent until their products are exposed to thousands of cyclists riding in a wide variety of conditions.
Before purchasing a power meter from an unfamiliar manufacturer, investigate its product history, warranty policies, customer support, independent reviews, and track record of firmware development. A company that offers an impressive list of specifications at an attractive price isn't necessarily offering the best long-term value.
Cycling equipment is exposed to rain, sweat, heat, cold, vibration, road debris, and considerable mechanical stress. Durability under real-world conditions is just as important as performance in a controlled testing environment.
I would rather purchase a proven power meter that reliably performs its fundamental functions than one that offers an impressive collection of advanced features but requires constant attention.
What Power Meter Manufacturers Should Focus On
In my opinion, the industry would benefit from placing greater emphasis on what the majority of cyclists actually need: straightforward installation, reliable measurements, intuitive configuration, broad compatibility, reasonable pricing, durable construction, and responsive customer support.
Advanced cycling dynamics, independent left/right analysis, and increasingly sophisticated performance metrics certainly have a place in the market. But they shouldn't come at the expense of making power measurement accessible and useful to the average cyclist.
A power meter can be one of the most valuable training investments a cyclist makes. It provides objective feedback, improves training precision, helps establish realistic pacing strategies, and allows performance improvements to be tracked over time. However, the device itself cannot make the cyclist faster. That requires an understanding of how to apply the information it provides.
Unless you're a self-confessed data junkie, don't pay for technology you're unlikely to use. Choose a power meter that fits your bicycle, your budget, your training objectives, and your tolerance for technology.
Simplicity, robustness, consistency, and flexibility may ultimately offer considerably more value than another half-percent improvement in advertised accuracy or another dozen performance metrics.
Think doorbell.
Recommended Reading: Cycling Power Meters and Training Technology
-
How to Choose a Bicycle Power Meter: 5 Questions to Ask Before You Buy
-
Single vs. Dual-Sided Power Meters: Do Cyclists Really Need Left/Right Power Analysis?
-
Training Technology: Does More Data Actually Improve Athletic Performance?
-
Match a Cycle Computer to Your Goal: What Data to Prioritize
-
The Frugal Triathlete: How to Save Money on Triathlon Gear Without Sacrificing Performance
By Coach Matt Russ
Coach Matt Russ enjoyed a professional coaching career spanning over two decades of working with professional endurance athletes. His athletes have achieved numerous regional, national, international and championship titles under his direction. Matt achieved the highest level of licensing by both USA Triathlon and USA Cycling, and was a licensed USA Track and Field Coach as well as a SICI Certified Bike Fitter. His accomplishments include being named "Team USA" Coach for the Beijing World Championship. Head Coach and founder of The Sport Factory, a USA Triathlon Certified Performance Center, he has authored many articles on a wide variety of endurance related topics.